ZB ZB
Live now
Start time
Playing for
End time
Listen live
Listen to NAME OF STATION
Up next
Listen live on
ZB

Try or no try? Rugby bosses weigh in on ABs v England

Author
NZ Herald ,
Publish Date
Mon, 12 Nov 2018, 9:13AM
The decision of the TMO Marius Jonker during the final minutes of the test sparked outrage in the rugby community, especially from fans and media in the UK.
The decision of the TMO Marius Jonker during the final minutes of the test sparked outrage in the rugby community, especially from fans and media in the UK.

Try or no try? Rugby bosses weigh in on ABs v England

Author
NZ Herald ,
Publish Date
Mon, 12 Nov 2018, 9:13AM

World Rugby has backed the controversial decision to disallow England's late try against the All Blacks in yesterday's test at Twickenham.

The decision of the TMO Marius Jonker during the final minutes of the test sparked outrage in the rugby community, especially from fans and media in the UK.

However, the Guardian reports that the sport's ruling body says the controversial call to rule out England flanker Sam Underhill's late try was the correct one.

"Under World Rugby directives a TMO trial was introduced for the most recent round of matches to give back responsibility to the on-field referee and it states that 'try scoring should be an on-field decision with the referee being responsible but the team of four [officials] can all contribute'," the Guardian reported.

"Although Garcès was within a few metres of Lawes at the time of the incident, he appeared to go against the directive by consulting with Jonker.

"Allowing Jonker to make the final decision would also seem to contravene the directive that requires "compelling evidence" for the TMO to intervene with World Rugby considering Lawes to have been marginally offside.

"Ultimately however, the governing body believes a number of mitigating factors meant Garcès was within his rights to defer the final decision to the TMO, chiefly the poor weather which made visibility of Twickenham's big screens more difficult."

All Blacks coach Steve Hansen praised the match officials after his side's 16-15 victory, saying they were brave to make what he called the "right decision".

"There was no doubt he was offside," said Hansen.

"He was just about in the halfback's back pocket. What was going through my mind was are they going to be brave enough to make the right decision and they were so it was good."

Meanwhile, England coach Eddie Jones was magnanimous in defeat and refused to blame the referees.

"I don't comment on those decisions I leave that up to that guy and if he can't make the right decision with 10 replays then who can," Jones said after the test.

"Sometimes the game loves you sometimes the game doesn't love you. You've got to accept that if you stay in the fight long enough the game will love you. We're prepared to stay in the game so we'll get some love further down the track don't worry."

The All Blacks will next face Ireland in Dublin on Sunday.

 

Take your Radio, Podcasts and Music with you