Keep up with
Newstalk ZB

Mon, 20 May 2013, 19:55

Have Your Say

Talkback 0800 80 10 80
Overseas +64 9 307 1080
Text 9292

Follow Us

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • RSS
  • Sign Up

Site Search

Search Search

Select your region:

Political Report: Consistently inconsistent

Share |

By: Felix Marwick | Friday, August 17, 2012 6:00 AM

If there's one thing I've noticed about politics, it's that the only consistent thing about it is its inconsistency.

A perfect illustration of this is the very divergent strategies that appear to apply to the issue of privacy.

Privacy breaches at ACC, for example, are a scourge on the face of the public service.

ACC Minister Judith Collins has made it a priority for the corporation to clean up its act in the face of repeated accidental releases of personal client information.

Not good enough and unacceptable are among the words Ms Collins has used to describe the situation from her office on the sixth floor of the Beehive.

Yet just one floor down a very different approach is being taken by Social Development Minister Paula Bennett.

She's neither resiled, nor apologised, for her decision in 2010 to release the welfare income details of beneficiary Natasha Fuller.

At the time Ms Fuller made public criticism of the Government's decision to cut training allowances for beneficiaries - what eventuated was the public finding out exactly what entitlements she was receiving.

Both the Privacy Commissioner and the Office of Human Rights Proceedings are of the opinion Ms Bennett breached Ms Fuller's privacy.

The Minister begs to differ, and hasn't ruling out taking similar steps should a similar situation arise in the future.

Deputy Prime Minister Bill English has made the argument being if someone chooses to enter a political debate, they have to expect some scrutiny of their position.

It's a fair point, but is using the full weight of the state to reveal someone's personal details they way to do it?

Paula Bennett could have easily asked if Natasha Fuller was prepared to reveal her income. Ms Fuller's response could have been used to judge the weight of her arguments

So what can we take from all of this?

A cynic would say it shows politicians are happy to change the rules when it suits them.

But what it does appear to reveal is that there are two rules - if you're a Government agency you mess with people's privacy at your peril, if you're a minister it's not such a big deal.

One would think even our politicians might consider that a double standard.

 

 

Ramblings of a Redhead: The Curse of Bea ...

Monday, May 20, 2013

I sighed with a heavy heart as a read this latest article on the Daily Mail ...

A new reality TV concept

Monday, May 20, 2013

I can't keep track of all these unreal reality shows. I don't try to but th ...

Mike's Editorial: Breakfast in schools m ...

Monday, May 20, 2013

There is allegedly an announcement coming on feeding kids in schools. Curr ...

Political Report: Rebranding for the Gre ...

Monday, May 20, 2013

The Kermits may have have dispensed with their socks and sandals and done a ...

Mike's Editorial: Budget reflections

Friday, May 17, 2013

I know it's as dry as dust and none of us apart from the odd numbers nerd o ...

Political Report: Giving with one hand, ...

Friday, May 17, 2013

The Dipton Drawler Bill English stepped up to the mark yesterday and looked ...

Advertisement
Mike Hosking Breakfast
Advertisement
  • NRL: Inu, Taylor charged by match review committee

  • NRL: Kingston on the hunt for a new club

  • NHL: Greening helps Senators to victory

  • Cricket: A positive out of the first England test

  • Shouting, then gunshots heard in fatal shooting

  • World Inflammatory Bowel Disease Day

  • No link between found vehicle & cold case

  • Uni student entitlement linked to poor exam result ...

  • Gavin Grey: euroscepticism and ...

  • David Shearer: the MMP review

  • Nathan Guy: the meat on Chines ...

  • Richard Burton: the Unitary Pl ...

  • Friday-Budget Passion

  • Thursday-Topless Research

  • Wednesday-Gilmore So Gone

  • Tuesday-Unconventional Centre

National Convention Centre

Do you support the Government's deal with SkyCity over the National Convention Centre

Vote Now

View Results